Bulletin of the World Health Organization

Mortality after near-miss obstetric complications in Burkina Faso: medical, social and health-care factors

Katerini T Storeng a, Seydou Drabo b, Rasmané Ganaba c, Johanne Sundby b, Clara Calvert d & Véronique Filippi d

a. Centre for Development and the Environment, University of Oslo, PB 1116 Blindern, Oslo 0317, Norway.
b. Institute of Health and Society, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
c. AFRICSanté, Bobo-Dioulasso, Burkina Faso.
d. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, England.

Correspondence to Katerini T Storeng (e-mail: Katerini.storeng@sum.uio.no).

(Submitted: 29 July 2011 – Revised version received: 18 November 2011 – Accepted: 23 January 2012 – Published online: 13 March 2012.)

Bulletin of the World Health Organization 2012;90:418-425C. doi: 10.2471/BLT.11.094011

Introduction

International discussions about maternal health in low-income countries tend to focus on maternal deaths. However, there is increasing concern that these deaths are only the tip of the iceberg in terms of the health effects of the poor availability and quality of maternity services.1 In addition, countries with high maternal mortality also have a large burden of pregnancy-related complications and associated disabilities. It is estimated that “for every woman who dies from a pregnancy-related cause, about 20 more – roughly 7 million women yearly – experience injury, infection, disease or disability”.1 Of growing interest are “near-miss” obstetric complications – complications so severe that they would probably have killed the woman had she not received timely medical care.2

In low-income countries, near misses are often considered obstetric successes because ultimately the woman’s life was saved by a focused medical intervention.2,3 However, little is known about long-term outcomes following these complications.4 Recent studies document a substantial degree of physical and psychological morbidity in their aftermath510 and the high cost of emergency obstetric care has serious social and economic consequences.11,12 Although women’s lives are known to remain at risk for several months beyond the 42-day cut-off used in standard definitions of maternal death,13 few studies have examined survival beyond this period in women who experience severe obstetric complications.

To what extent does surviving a near-miss obstetric complication mean that a maternal death has actually been averted? Our aim was to investigate maternal mortality in the 4 years after hospital discharge following a near-miss complication in Burkina Faso. We used data from a longitudinal, mixed-methods, cohort study to describe patterns of mortality and analysed the medical, social and health-care-related causes of death after near-miss complications. Finally, we considered the implications of our study findings for strategies that promote safe motherhood.

Methods

Study setting

Burkina Faso is an impoverished country in western Africa that is ranked 177th out of 182 countries in terms of human development; 81% of the population live on less than 2 United States dollars a day.14 The country’s scores on reproductive health indicators are among the worst in the world. The fertility rate is 6.2 children per woman.15 According to the most recent national census,16 the maternal mortality ratio is 307 per 100 000 live births, and the World Health Organization’s estimate is 560 per 100 000 live births.17 Burkina Faso’s district health system functions poorly and existing safe motherhood programmes do not address the availability of comprehensive obstetric care.18 Only 73.2% of births are assisted by a skilled birth attendant – a figure that hides significant regional and socioeconomic disparities.19 User fees for maternal health care, especially emergency care, are often unaffordable.11 In 2007, the health ministry introduced an 80% subsidy for facility-based delivery to reduce out-of-pocket expenditure,20 but its effect is still unclear.21,22

Data collection

We followed a cohort of 1014 women for 4 years after they were discharged from seven hospitals across Burkina Faso between November 2004 and March 2005. Women were recruited at hospital discharge to avoid exposure misclassification.23 Of the 1014 women in the cohort, 337 had experienced a near-miss obstetric complication: the pregnancy ended in a live birth in 199 cases, in a perinatal death in 74 and in a miscarriage, ectopic pregnancy or abortion in 64. For each woman who had a near miss, we recruited an average of two unmatched controls from the seven hospitals. Usually the next two women to have an uncomplicated live delivery, as confirmed by medical notes, were selected, though some hospitals recruited more controls than others. The total number of controls was 677.

Trained lay interviewers made six follow-up visits: on day three after discharge, at 3 months, 6 months and 12 months, and in the third and fourth years after the end of the pregnancy. We investigated whether any woman not found for the interview had moved away or died. Interviews explored women’s health, reproductive history, socioeconomic status, experience of health care, and health-care costs. Medical information was extracted from routine hospital records at discharge and from reports of medical examinations conducted 6 and 12 months later. In parallel, anthropologists carried out a detailed follow-up of a subsample of 82 women: 64 had near misses and 18 had uncomplicated deliveries. Findings from the first year of follow-up have been reported elsewhere.8,11,12

We used the verbal autopsy method to make detailed enquiries about any woman who died. This approach determines the cause of death by asking lay respondents about the signs exhibited and the symptoms experienced by the deceased and is used when data from routine information systems are incomplete.24 Generally, respondents were the woman’s husband, relatives who had participated closely in the woman’s care and, when possible, health workers. A physician conducted verbal autopsies at the end of the first year, and the anthropologist conducted interviews at the end of follow-up. Additionally, an open-ended in-depth interview or social autopsy25,26 was carried out to identify any social or health-care-related factors that could have contributed to the death.

Data analysis

The proportion of women who survived at each follow-up visit was calculated for women who experienced near misses and for those who had uncomplicated deliveries. We used Fisher’s exact test to determine whether the post-discharge mortality rate differed significantly between the two groups. We compared the marital status, age and parity at baseline of women who survived and who died within 4 years of follow-up in both the group of women who had uncomplicated deliveries and in the group that had near misses. We used the chi squared test to assess the association between baseline characteristics and death.

The most likely medical cause of death was assigned independently and agreed on by two clinical researchers on the basis of data from the verbal autopsy combined with additional information from medical records and reports of medical examinations (Table 1, available at: http://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/90/6/11-094011). Comorbid conditions that may have contributed to the death were taken into account. In addition, we analysed records of the in-depth interviews thematically to derive non-medical causes of death.27 This analysis was guided by our knowledge of the social circumstances of women in Burkina Faso and the health systems they use, gained over the course of the study.11,12 Moreover, two of the deceased women belonged to the anthropologists’ subsample and had participated in several interviews before their deaths.

Ethical approval

The study was approved by the ethics committees of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the Ministry of Health of Burkina Faso. Study participants gave their free and informed consent.

Results

Mortality

Fig. 1 shows the number of participants included at each stage of the study. Of the 1014 women recruited, 695 attended the final interview at the end of the 4-year follow-up and 20 had died. Post-discharge mortality was significantly higher among women who had a near-miss obstetric complication than among controls who had uncomplicated deliveries (P < 0.001). Fig. 2 shows the proportion of women who survived at each follow-up visit. Six (1.9%) women in the near-miss group died within 1 year, and none died in the control group. The corresponding figures at the end of the 4-year follow-up period were 15 (5.3%) and 5 (0.9%) in the two groups, respectively.

Fig. 1. Study participants, maternal mortality in the 4 years after pregnancy, Burkina Faso, 2004–2009
Fig. 1. Study participants, maternal mortality in the 4 years after pregnancy, Burkina Faso, 2004–2009
a Some women missed one interview but attended a later one, so were not counted as being lost to follow-up.
Fig. 2. Maternal survival after the end of pregnancy, by pregnancy outcome, Burkina Faso, 2004–2009
Fig. 2. <b>Maternal survival after the end of pregnancy, by pregnancy outcome, Burkina Faso, 2004–2009</b>
a A near-miss complication is a severe obstetric complication that would probably kill the woman without timely medical care.

No significant difference was found in age (P = 0.47) or parity at baseline (P = 0.42) between women in the near-miss group who died and those who survived and completed follow-up. However, women who died were more likely to be single at baseline (P = 0.001; Table 2). We could draw no such comparisons in the control group because of the small number of deaths.

Medical causes of death

Verbal autopsy data were available for 18 of the 20 deaths (Table 1). The relatives of the remaining two women could not be located.

In the near-miss group, 9 of the 15 deaths (60%) were pregnancy-related, compared with none in the control group (Table 1). Moreover, six of these nine pregnancy-related deaths occurred within 1 year of the near-miss obstetric complication or the end of the pregnancy. The most likely medical causes of these six deaths were: organ failure following septic abortion in one woman with a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection; tuberculosis related to HIV infection in one woman with puerperal sepsis; anaemia with possible sepsis or immunity problems in one woman; probable anaemia in one; infection in one; and hypertension (i.e. eclampsia) in one. The remaining three pregnancy-related deaths in the near-miss group occurred within 42 days of a subsequent pregnancy: one was due to hypertension, one to septic abortion and one to haemorrhage following caesarean section suture complications. At least three of the nine women who died from a pregnancy-related cause were HIV-positive. The causes of the remaining six deaths in the near-miss group were: HIV infection in one, hypertension in one, possible infection related to tuberculosis in one, a suspected traffic accident in one and unknown due to insufficient data in two.

Of the five deaths in the control group, one was caused by malaria and three by acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS); the cause of one death remained undetermined due to insufficient data. The contribution of HIV infection and tuberculosis to deaths in the two groups is notable.

By the end of follow-up, three of the seven babies born to women who had a near-miss complication and who subsequently died had also died. One of the babies died a few days before his mother, at the age of 28 days. This baby was probably born with intrauterine growth retardation. The other two died after their mothers: one from malnutrition at 5 months and one from an unknown cause at 15 months. No deaths occurred among the five babies born to women in the control group who subsequently died. These babies were older at the time of their mothers’ deaths and therefore less vulnerable.

Health-care-related and social causes of deaths

Relatives of the women who died within a year of a near-miss complication believed the women had been discharged prematurely. Correspondingly,17% of these women had not fully recovered when discharged, according to medical records.8 Some left hospital because they could no longer afford to pay for care or to remain absent from their regular activities. Inadequate follow-up of unresolved health problems may have compounded the burden of premature discharge, as in the case of a 25-year-old woman who died of sepsis 7 months after an unsafe abortion (Box 1). As a whole, respondents noted that poor links between different parts of the health-care system (e.g. between a district hospital and a national hospital) delayed or prevented access to care.

Box 1. Example of a late pregnancy-related death after a near-miss complication,a Burkina Faso, 2005

The 25-year-old womanb moved from a rural village to a town to work in a bar. She became pregnant while in a relationship with a visiting bureaucrat. Her partner revealed he was married with children, pressured her to terminate the pregnancy and paid for an illegal abortion. She was hospitalized with a near-miss septic abortion after intense stomach aches resulting from the botched abortion, underwent manual vacuum aspiration for the incomplete abortion and was treated for infection before discharge. She suffered stigmatization, lost her income and job and became disillusioned. An unresolved abortion-related infection left untreated due to the cost of care resulted in another hospitalization 6 months after discharge. The woman’s brothers paid for her hospitalization for more than 1 month but were unable to afford prescribed referral to a tertiary hospital in a major city 170 km away. The woman died at her brothers’ home 7 months after the septic abortion. The brothers had substantial financial problems even 3 years after the woman’s death: they were in debt, had lost income and their farm’s yield was reduced because they had to sell some animals to cover the health-care costs.

a A near-miss complication is a severe obstetric complication that would probably kill the women without timely medical care.
b Woman 4 in Table 1

Similarly, relatives of the three women in the near-miss group who died of pregnancy-related causes after a subsequent pregnancy identified a range of health-care-related contributing factors. None of these women received specific follow-up during antenatal care despite having had a near-miss complication in a recent pregnancy. The reason may be that in Burkina Faso no midwife and certainly no specialist normally participates in antenatal care, which is often delivered in a ritualistic way without addressing chronic ailments or risk factors. An unmet need for contraception, which is costly and poorly available, contributed to one of the maternal deaths because it led to an unwanted pregnancy. According to this woman’s husband, the new pregnancy exacerbated the hypertension that resulted in the near miss less than 2 years earlier (Box 2). Both relatives and health-care workers strongly believed that better care could have saved the woman, who died of haemorrhage following caesarean section suture complications. She was discharged from hospital prematurely – within 24 hours of the emergency caesarean section – and was left untreated overnight, then readmitted with heavy bleeding and an open caesarean section wound the following evening. She died the next morning.

Box 2. Example of a maternal death from a new pregnancy after a near-miss complication,a Burkina Faso, 2006–8

The 23-year-old Muslim womanb divorced after the death of her first child and was betrothed to a subsistence farmer, a relative, as his second wife. She experienced a stillbirth after a near-miss delivery involving eclampsia; the resulting health-care expenditure was ”catastrophic” for the hous ehold. She had difficulty participating in household activities due to chronic ill health related to hypertension that started in pregnancy. The support of her partner and his co-wife enabled the woman to be temporarily absent from subsistence agricultural work and domestic chores. She took medication only on alternate weeks due to its cost. She wanted to delay a new pregnancy but was unable to acquire appropriate contraception because it was costly and unavailable at the local health centre. She had a new pregnancy within 1 year of the near-miss complication. The new pregnancy was difficult because of hypertension and she had a hospital delivery. She became ill in the postpartum period and died while asleep 28 days after delivery, most likely from hypertensive disease. The baby died shortly afterwards. Her husband was financially “ruined” by the health-care expenditure, which was exacerbated by new responsibilities for the widow and three children of a brother who had died.

a A near-miss complication is a severe obstetric complication that would probably kill the women without timely medical care.
b Woman 8 in Table 1

Relatives regarded the women’s deaths as particularly tragic in light of the resources initially invested in saving them after the near miss and in treating subsequent associated health problems. Cost barriers disrupted referral chains for these women and impeded access to care for chronic health complaints, which may have indirectly or directly contributed to their deaths (Box 1). The cost barrier was particularly high for women with chronic health conditions. Lack of or inadequate treatment of pregnancy-related ailments, such as puerperal infection and anaemia, or of underlying infections or chronic conditions, such as hypertension, HIV infection, tuberculosis or malaria, appear to have contributed to several maternal deaths. These difficulties were exacerbated by social disadvantage, including a lack of social and material support, especially among single women.

Discussion

Our findings show that the limited availability and poor quality of maternal health-care services can lead not only to immediate death or longer-term disability or illness in women who experience a near miss from severe pregnancy complications, but also to an increased risk of death as long as 4 years after the event. Although targeted emergency care initially saved many women who experienced obstetric complications, those who had a near miss were significantly more likely to die within the next 4 years than those who had an uncomplicated hospital delivery. Notably, these women had a higher risk of dying from a pregnancy-related cause, whether associated with the initial near miss or with the complications of a subsequent pregnancy. Single women were at a particularly high risk, perhaps because of poor material and social support. In addition, an infant born to a woman who had a near miss and subsequently died was also at an increased risk of death. The risk was higher both after the mother’s death and before, as the mother may have been too sick or poor to produce breast milk or to properly care for her infant.28 By contrast, no women with an uncomplicated delivery died from a pregnancy-related cause, and the babies of those who did die survived. Although we lack survival data on women lost to follow-up, we observed that those who had a near miss were more often lost to follow-up than those who did not. Consequently, unrecorded deaths were more likely among these women than among controls.

The verbal autopsy approach used in this study has well-known limitations, including recall bias, since data are sometimes collected months or years after a death.24,29 The validity and reliability of lay respondents’ reports of medical symptoms can also be problematic; their descriptions can be vague and non-medical and can point to a diagnosis that differs from the physician’s. Moreover, respondents cannot provide information on signs that are not detectable without laboratory testing or clinical autopsy. Although verbal autopsies cannot unequivocally identify the immediate cause of death or exclude competing causes, they can indicate the most likely contributing factors. In the absence of death registries, verbal autopsies provide the best means of identifying the likely medical cause of death.

Women clearly remain at risk of a pregnancy-related death for longer than the 42 days used in standard definitions of maternal death.30 Consequently, the contribution of pregnancy-related deaths to mortality among women of reproductive age is likely to be underestimated. Indeed, extending the definition to include all deaths within 3 months of delivery increases current estimates of maternal mortality in low-income settings by 10% to 15%.3032 Incorporating late maternal deaths within 1 year of the end of pregnancy would further increase the figure.

Current assessment methods may underrepresent indirect causes of maternal death, which could be aggravated by pregnancy.33 Our study showed that comorbid conditions, such as HIV/AIDS, and diseases of poverty, such as anaemia, contributed to late pregnancy-related deaths after a near miss. Except for direct obstetric complications, HIV infection was the most important contributor to pregnancy-related deaths in our study. This finding supports recent analyses that highlight the contribution of HIV infection to high maternal mortality rates in Africa.34

Our analysis of the structural constraints that limited access to health care and reduced the quality of the care received by women in our study helped us to understand the broader circumstances leading to their deaths. The relatives of women who died highlighted various possible contributing factors: premature hospital discharge; poor postpartum follow-up; inadequately treated underlying conditions; unmet need for contraception; lack of appropriate antenatal care, and inadequate emergency obstetric care in subsequent pregnancies.35 Although firm general conclusions about the health-care system cannot be drawn without supporting data from health-care providers and other stakeholders, studies from Burkina Faso11,18 and other high-mortality countries36 support our informants’ reports that poor service supply and demand act as barriers to maternal health care, both during and after pregnancy.

Policy implications

Because most maternal and neonatal deaths occur around the time of delivery,13 the maternal health strategy throughout the world has long emphasized intrapartum care. This includes skilled birth attendance for all women and emergency obstetric care to prevent maternal death from direct causes such as haemorrhage, obstructed labour, hypertension, infection and anaemia.37 However, although good intrapartum care can ensure safe delivery, it does not suffice to prevent death in the aftermath of severe complications, sometimes over the long term.

Our study findings on the indirect causes of maternal death, the weaknesses in the health-care system and the social and structural barriers to health care suggest the need for a more comprehensive, life-cycle approach to women’s health. The solution may be longer and more differentiated clinical management, including family planning. Moreover, we also found that underlying chronic health problems increase the risk of maternal death. The solution may be integrated health care, with integration across the entire reproductive cycle (i.e. family planning, pregnancy and delivery care, and postpartum care) and across different vertical treatment programmes, and with integration of specialist and generalist care.

It has become evident in recent years that a well-functioning health-care system and the provision of a continuum of care are essential for achieving the United Nations Millenium Development Goals pertaining to health. For instance, international policy-makers postulate a continuum of care for maternal, neonatal and child health that involves integrating health care for these different groups across time and place.38 Such a continuum would include postpartum care as a priority and provide links between reproductive and sexual health-care services and maternal health care. In addition, ways of simultaneously addressing the social and economic determinants of health are receiving increasing attention.39

Despite these policy changes and the greater priority afforded to maternal health both internationally and nationally,40 achieving a comprehensive continuum of care remains challenging. For example, few health-care services address the specific needs of women in the year following childbirth.5 More often, safe motherhood programmes in low-income countries, including Burkina Faso, are implemented vertically and focus almost exclusively on the birth period. They rarely address the underlying factors that undermine health, such as economic and social disadvantage, chronic health problems and poor access to individual, continuous and preventive health care.

In conclusion, surviving a near-miss obstetric complication is no guarantee that a pregnancy-related death has been averted. In Burkina Faso, women who experienced a near-miss complication had a higher risk of all-cause and pregnancy-related death, even 4 years later, due to a combination of medical, social and health-care-related factors. Current safe motherhood programmes emphasize emergency intrapartum obstetric care that targets the direct causes of maternal mortality. These programmes are insufficient for tackling excess mortality over the longer term. Survival in this period requires the introduction of a comprehensive continuum of care that addresses the indirect and social causes of death.


Acknowledgements

The authors thank Mélanie Akoum, Oona Campbell, Patrick Ilboudo, Birgit Kvernflaten, Hanne Lichtwarck, Tom Marshall, Nicolas Meda, Susan Murray, Fatoumata Ouattara, Thomas Ouédraogo, Carine Ronsmans, Steven Russell, Henri Somé, seminar participants at the University of Uppsala and the Christian Michelsen Institute in Bergen and all women, their relatives, health workers and interviewers involved in the study.

Funding:

Immpact, the Hewlett Foundation and the UK Economic and Social Research Council (Grant number RES-183-25-0011) funded the first stages of the study. The Research Council of Norway’s ECONPOP programme (Project number 199730/H30) supported verbal autopsy data collection and analysis.

Competing interests:

None declared.

References

Share